A few weeks ago we went on a Tiyul to the Old City of Jerusalem, focusing on the Herodian Mansions and the Southern Wall.
In the Herodian Mansions lived the social group called the Saducces. They were on good terms with the Romans and although the Temple and the Jewish Religion was the center of their life, they still were quite assimilated with Roman culture. In these Mansions we found evidence of their higher social class as well as both Jewish and Roman culture. We saw their social class i the size of the houses. Common in most of the Mansions were a spacious expanse for the time. Also, most, if not all, of the houses had multiple rooms and luxuries that poorer classes could not afford such as a personal bathtub. Their connection to the Jewish religion was seen in that there were also Mikvahs in the houses of the Saducces. The Saduccees were the priestly class of Jerusalem in the time of the Beit Hamikdash. Because of this they needed to go in and out of the temple a lot. For the purity of the temple they had to keep themselves spiritually clean at all times so they installed mikvahs in their houses. The presence of Roman culture in their own lives could be seen with some of the accommodations in their house which remain. These include mosaics on the floors and walls as well as frescos, plaster with paint designs over it, and Roman-style columns.
At the Southern Wall, we studied the Beit Hamikdash and the role it played in society when it was in use for sacrifices and such. The Temple was in use for the whole nation during the 3 main festivals of the year, Passover, Shavuot, and Sukkot. For these 3 festivals, pilgrims from all across the land of Israel would come from wherever they lived to make a sacrifice at the temple. The process of making a sacrifice was a long arduous one (It was spelled out pretty well in that weird video with the cup obsession if that helps jog your memory). It started back in whatever village or place the pilgrims came from. They would stock up on food and make a weeks long journey to Jerusalem. Upon arriving, their one concern is being able to sacrifice. The first requirement for a sacrifice is a half shekel tax which must be paid. They pay this tax, then buy an animal to sacrifice. After buying an animal, the pilgrims would travel to the mikvah on the western side of the complex. We actually followed in the footsteps of our ancestors and went in this mikvah on this Tiyul. Following the MIkvah, the pilgrims would join thousands of other pilgrims on the steps of the Southern Wall, slowly walking up the awkwardly spaced steps to the 3 Arches which acted as entryways. A fun fact about th
ese doors which we learned is that the majority of people entered through these 3 Arches in the Southern wall but people who were in mourning or exiled from their communities entered through a separate door, those who had either lost someone or lost themselves. Once through the arches, a priest would say a prayer and then you would offer your sacrifice. From there you would then exit the complex and join the community once again. This community is what made these sacrifices even more special than just the opportunity to sacrifice. Tens of thousands of people would come to the Beit Hamikdash, people from all different backgrounds, all different places, for the same purpose. This created a massive kehilah kidoshah, a special community of which everyone in the nation was part.
The process of making a sacrifice must have been awe inspiring. Coming to the Temple, a massive structure, the holiest place in the world, with thousands of other pilgrims just like you, juxtaposed with the small village lifestyle of most people during that time, would have been almost unbelievable to experience (once again I’d like to take your memories back to the weird cup-obsessed video because it does a very good job of capturing the momentousness of the occasion). Thinking about this process in the context of today, we share a similar experience in that each time we pray, we pray towards Jerusalem and towards the Temple Mount, spiritually traveling to Jerusalem as a community, just as our ancestors did physically. This Tiyul made me realize how important the Temple Mount is to Judaism. We, as an international Jewish community all pray facing the same place, all metaphorically praying together.
Our glorious leader Evan, said to us that the destruction of the second temple in 70 CE by the Romans is the most central event in Jewish history. This set back the Judaism of the time a massive amount and effectively changed the center of worship from the Temple to the Synagogue with Rabbinical Judaism as the Pharisees were the group of Jews which continued. With this tragedy, the practice of Judaism at the time took a massive step backwards. Do you think that Judaism has "recovered," from the destruction of the temple with the form that modern Judaism has taken?





I don't think Judaism will ever recover from the fall of the temple because it was such an important part to the religion as a place to worship and one of the most holy places for the Jews. I do think the way Judaism is modernizing it helping with the recovery. We are slowly making our way towards needing the temple less but still we will never fully recover from the fall of the temple.
ReplyDeleteThis was also a super awesome tiyul, but to answer your question, I think that the fall of the temple allowed judaism to change into what it is today, I find that fascinating. In recovering from the temple destruction, Judaism has change how people pray, what rules to follow, and how to live. The temple being destroyed obviously will ring in Jewish history forever, but I think that is amazing how people have chosen to build up from that. Awesome blog.
ReplyDeleteI think that Judaism has recovered from the fall of the second temple. We've created a culture where everyone attends temple. They only had one temple in their period, but now we've revitalized the idea of a community space for poeple to pray in together, so I think we've recovered and made Judaism what it was (if not better than it was) in the second temple period.
ReplyDeleteI think it depends on who is answering that question. For me, I think that judaism as a whole has absolutely recovered from the destruction of the temple, but I think that in particular those who are in favor of creating a third temple would disagree. Modern judaism has not only recovered, but thrived. Would the third temple be used for sacrifices? I just feel like Judaism has evolved to a point where a temple is unnecessary.
ReplyDeleteI would not say that Judaism recovered, rather it progressed forward. Almost none of modern Judaism is what was practiced in the times of the temple. However, Judaism continues to be alive. It has developed rapidly and widely. Jews have never stopped acknowledging their faith, and have made it their own in a variety of ways. Each of these ways are different from that of the time of the temple, which will never be truly recovered.
ReplyDeleteI believe that it has mostly recovered from the fall, but it was definitely changed. I think that it has affected the way people pray and how they believe. I don't think that it is a necessity in this day and age because of how much everything has evolved. Now the religion doesn't need a certain place, Judaism is widespread and people have been able to break free from the old rules like sacrifice. It has improved and modernized after the destruction and I don't think it would be needed to rebuild.
ReplyDeleteFirst off I would like to say how awesome and thoughtful this post was. Second I think rather than recover, Judaism has changed and adapted over time after the fall of the second temple. The Jews were forced to find new ways to pray and follow their traditions, which I think helped them continue to adapt in the future.
ReplyDeleteI don't believe that we as a people have, or ever will completely recover from the destruction of the Beit Hamikdash, rather we are in a constant but slow recovery. We may or may not be living in our best times today, however we are definitely not living through the worst of times. I think the way that Judaism has bloomed over time is beautiful and that things are only getting better. I'm not doubting that there will be tough times for us in the future, but "what doesn't kill us makes us stronger." boom bang bang
ReplyDeleteI am not sure that Judaism has recovered from the destruction of the temple, but the Jews were able to carry on with their religion and continue to prosper. The fact that people practise Judaism around the world shows how determined we are to keep our religion alive. This has helped us move past the tragedy of the destruction of the temple.
ReplyDeleteI think the Jews as a whole have recovered. Over the years the Jews have grown and recovered in many ways, the destruction of the temple was a very difficult time since it was such an important part of the Jewish people, but we have definitely recovered and are not affected by the loss of this place.
ReplyDeleteI think judism has recovered in the way of a reformed movement as a whole, but maybe not in an orthodox mans eyes, or someone who sees/wants the third temple to be built. since the second temple was such a idolized place at the time I dont know if everyone will actually ever be satisfied.
ReplyDeleteI believe we have done more than recover. Without this destruction we may never have developed t'filah, which is central to Judaism today. We might still be sacrificing animals as we barbarically did in biblical times.
ReplyDeleteI believe that we 100% have recovered. Today we have developed and created the t'filah which is one of the most important things in Judaism. Although the fall of the Second Temple was a great loss, I believe the gain from it can not go unnoticed.
ReplyDelete